Netflix has once again ventured into history with its latest limited series, Death by Lightning, a powerful retelling of the life and untimely assassination of U.S. President James A. Garfield. Blending political intrigue with human vulnerability, the show transforms a largely forgotten chapter of American history into gripping, award-worthy storytelling.
A Forgotten President Reborn
The series, starring Michael Shannon as President Garfield and Matthew Macfadyen as Vice President Chester A. Arthur, adds new depth to a story that few modern viewers are familiar with in detail. Garfield, elected in 1880, was one of the shortest-serving presidents in U.S. history—assassinated just months after taking office by Charles Guiteau, a disgruntled job-seeker convinced he was owed a political reward.
Netflix’s adaptation doesn’t just recount his death—it reconstructs the emotional, political, and moral landscape of a country still reeling from the Civil War. Every frame radiates period authenticity, from dimly lit corridors of Washington power to the candlelit hospital rooms where Garfield clung to life.
Stellar Performances and Direction
Director Mike Barker (known for The Handmaid’s Tale) crafts an atmosphere of paranoia and destiny. Shannon captures Garfield’s intelligence and moral conviction, while Macfadyen gives a nuanced portrayal of a man thrust into leadership through tragedy.
The chemistry between the two actors transforms the political drama into a character study about ambition, honor, and guilt. The result feels less like a history lesson and more like an emotional reckoning—something Netflix historical dramas have often struggled to achieve.
Script, Tone, and Cinematic Craft
The writing by Mike Lerner walks a fine line between authentic period dialogue and modern pacing. Viewers are never overwhelmed by historical jargon, yet the narrative never sacrifices accuracy for the sake of spectacle.
Cinematographer Christopher Ross envelops the story in a sepia-toned palette—dark, moody, and storm-charged, reinforcing the symbolic “lightning” that frames both Garfield’s rise and fall.
Historical Accuracy Meets Modern Relevance
What makes Death by Lightning remarkable is its effort to remain historically faithful while resonating with contemporary audiences. Themes of corruption, political division, and media sensationalism mirror today’s headlines, making Garfield’s story tragically timeless.
Netflix also partnered with historical consultants to ensure accuracy in costume design, set pieces, and medical details surrounding Garfield’s prolonged death—ironically worsened by outdated medical practices rather than the bullet itself.
Critical Reception and Audience Buzz
Early reviews from outlets like TIME, The Boston Globe, and The Washington Post praise the series for its restraint and depth. Critics describe it as “a slow burn masterpiece” that combines the moral intensity of The Crown with the aesthetic gravitas of Lincoln.
Audiences on social media are equally captivated, applauding how the show educates without preaching and entertains without distortion.
“This is what prestige historical television should be—intimate, honest, and visually unforgettable.” — The Boston Globe
Key Cast & Crew Overview
| Role | Actor | Notable Works |
|---|---|---|
| James A. Garfield | Michael Shannon | Revolutionary Road, The Shape of Water |
| Chester A. Arthur | Matthew Macfadyen | Succession, Pride & Prejudice |
| Charles Guiteau | Nick Offerman | The Last of Us, Parks and Recreation |
| Director | Mike Barker | The Handmaid’s Tale |
| Writer | Mike Lerner | The Killing of President Garfield |
Why It Matters
Death by Lightning is more than just another period drama—it’s a reminder of democracy’s fragility. Garfield’s presidency may have lasted only 200 days, but his vision for merit-based governance and racial equality echoes throughout the series.
By dramatizing his story, Netflix positions the show not merely as entertainment but as a mirror for modern leadership and accountability.
Quick Facts
- Episodes: 6 (limited series)
- Release Date: November 2025
- Genre: Historical Drama / Political Thriller
- Platform: Netflix
- Based on: The real-life assassination of U.S. President James A. Garfield (1881)
Final Thoughts
Netflix’s Death by Lightning is a haunting, beautifully executed reminder that history repeats itself—often when power and ego collide. With exceptional performances and striking visuals, it stands among Netflix’s most refined works of 2025.
If you’re a fan of The Crown, The Assassination of Gianni Versace, or Lincoln, this series belongs at the top of your watchlist.
FAQs
1. Is Death by Lightning based on a true story?
Yes. It’s rooted in the real-life assassination of President James A. Garfield in 1881.
2. Who plays President Garfield in the Netflix series?
Michael Shannon delivers a commanding and emotional portrayal of Garfield.
3. When was Death by Lightning released on Netflix?
The limited series premiered globally in November 2025.
4. How many episodes does the show have?
It’s a concise six-episode drama ideal for weekend viewing.
5. Why is it called “Death by Lightning”?
The title is symbolic—representing both the speed and unpredictability of Garfield’s downfall.
Read the official coverage on TIME Magazine for more insights on the making of Death by Lightning.
